‘Dapat isa lang’, 1

WE HAVE been living with political dynasties for so long that we have learned to joke about them. Father is mayor. Mother is in Congress. The son is vice mayor. A daughter or cousin is waiting for the next opening.

When somebody reaches the term limit, another relative steps forward, almost like changing drivers on a long trip. In some towns, the positions change more often than the surnames do. We laugh about it over coffee because that is what Filipinos often do with things that have become too familiar to remain surprising.

I have written about dynasties before, and one thing still bothers me about the usual argument. It too quickly becomes a debate over whether political families are good or bad. Real life is not that tidy. I have no difficulty believing that a good politician can have an equally capable daughter, brother, or spouse. Some political families have served their communities well. Being born into the “wrong” surname should not automatically make a person less worthy of public service.

The discomfort begins somewhere else: when a family becomes so established in politics that everyone outside it has to fight through decades of accumulated advantage just to be noticed.

The Supreme Court has now forced that old problem back onto the table. In its August 26 decision, announced in September, the Court unanimously declared that Congress has a mandatory constitutional duty to enact an anti-political dynasty law. It also ruled that 39 years of failure to do so amounted to grave abuse of discretion (Kapatiran Party v. Congress of the Philippines, 2026).

The Constitution says the State “shall” guarantee equal access to opportunities for public service and prohibit political dynasties as defined by law. Thirty-nine years later, the Court has basically said: that sentence was meant to mean something.

There is an important qualification. Political dynasties did not suddenly become illegal the morning after the decision. The Court did not decide which relatives should be covered or how far the prohibition should reach. It did not disqualify candidates with famous surnames.

Congress still has to complete the lawmaking process. In fact, the House had already passed its anti-dynasty bill before the ruling. What changed is that the Court has now made the constitutional duty unmistakable: Congress still decides how political dynasties will be defined, but it cannot leave that mandate unfinished indefinitely. After almost four decades, “we are still studying it” begins to sound a little thin.

Then there is Dapat Isa Lang. The movement is taking another route, using the people’s initiative to propose an anti-dynasty law directly. Its published proposal reaches relatives within the fourth civil degree and places restrictions on family members holding or succeeding to elective positions.

Here in Iloilo, the Jaro Archdiocesan Social Action Center has joined the campaign. Suddenly, something usually discussed in constitutional law classes and congressional hearings is being talked about in parishes, schools, community gatherings, group chats, and probably a few tables where coffee lasts longer than intended.

One phrase from the campaign is worth holding onto: Dapat Alam. Know first. Before signing anything, read it. Ask what fourth degree means. Ask which positions are covered. Ask what happens to relatives who have genuinely independent careers. Ask how succession rules would work. Ask how the proposal prevents families from simply finding another way around the restriction.

Supporting an anti-dynasty law does not require switching off one’s skepticism. (To be continued)/PN

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here