
By ADRIAN STEWART CO
MANILA — Vice President Sara Duterte-Carpio’s defense team sought to undermine allegations that Cale88 Foods Corporation was an implausible business by presenting a Department of Trade and Industry (DTI) official who confirmed the company’s registration as a micro, small and medium enterprise (MSME).
DTI Undersecretary and Board of Investments (BOI) head Ceferino Rodolfo told the Senate impeachment court on Friday that Cale88 qualified as an MSME because its project cost was below P15 million.
“Ito po (Cale88) ay MSME dahil po sa project cost niya, below P15 million,” Rodolfo testified on the 45th day of Duterte-Carpio’s impeachment trial.
He confirmed that Cale88’s application for a Certificate of Registration of an Export Enterprise was evaluated and approved by the BOI extension office in Davao.
Rodolfo explained that the BOI decentralized MSME application processing in 2016, authorizing regional offices to evaluate and approve businesses within their jurisdictions.
“We streamlined the BOI system in 2016 for MSMEs under a Board Resolution, meaning the evaluation and approval [of a business] is now delegated function. This means that is the business is in Luzon, it would be under the Executive Director of Industry Development Service. Outside Luzon, it will depend on the jurisdiction of BOI Extension Office. Para dito po [sa Cale88], BOI Extension Office sa Davao ‘yung nag evaluate at nag approve,” he said.
He added that the Davao office’s evaluation report contained no recorded objections to Cale88’s application.
“Dahil po sa na-register po siya, ina-assume ko lang po na wala po nakuhang objection ‘yung Davao office po natin [sa Cale88 application for Certificate of Registration of an Export Enterprise]. Wala po akong nakita dun sa kanilang evaluation report na merong nag-object,” Rodolfo said.
He also clarified that MSMEs such as Cale88 were exempt from publishing their registration certificates in newspapers, with notices instead posted on the BOI website.
“This requirement does not apply to Cale88 being an MSME. What we do is we post the notice [of its Certificate of Registration of an Export Enterprise] on our BOI website kasi medyo mahal rin po mag-publish sa newspaper of general circulation,” he said.
Defense lawyer Justin Gular argued that the testimony challenged prosecution financial forensic expert Alex Cabrera’s characterization of Cale88 as an implausible business model.
“The exact term, Your Honor, if I may, by the supposed forensic expert is that Cale88 is allegedly an implausible business model. And of course, we seek to dispute, among other things, that monies were received by Mans Carpio from this corporation,” Gular said.
Cabrera previously estimated that Duterte-Carpio and her husband, Manases Carpio, could have accumulated between P817 million and P1.5 billion in unexplained wealth, allegedly involving undeclared assets and income, including transactions linked to Cale88.
Despite the defense’s reliance on Cale88’s registration, another defense witness, anti-money laundering consultant Rainer Dela Fuente, acknowledged Thursday that the company’s operations raised several red flags.
These included its reported two-person workforce, P319 million in remittances from China, and 757 covered and suspicious transactions totaling P1.2 billion.
Dela Fuente maintained, however, that such indicators did not automatically prove illegal activity./PN






