
MANILA — The defense lawyers of former President Rodrigo Duterte are opposing the introduction as evidence two supplemental studies cited by one of the prosecution’s expert witnesses, for lack of substance.
According to an Oct. 30 filing released only on Saturday, the defense is urging the Trial Chamber (TC) III to reject the prosecution’s request to admit as evidence additional materials mentioned by witness “P-1400” in a report.
The defense, led by British barrister Peter Haynes, noted that the additional reports were done by other professionals who are not on its witness list and merely served as supplements to P-1400’s own report.
P-1400, it added, had not “meaningfully used or explained” the two studies and therefore “are not integral” to the evidence already on hand.
“The chamber has held that it must analyse each item of associated material to determine its relevance and probative value, which is necessarily linked to the extent to which a witness discusses it in their prior recorded testimony,” the defense said in the eight-page document.
The two reports being sought for admission into evidence by the prosecution have no “substance consideration” in the case.
In a filing on Oct. 21, the prosecutors asked TC III to admit as evidence the reports and other associated materials provided by a witness P-1400 identified only as an “expert.”
They said the testimony and report provided would be of assistance to the chamber and would help streamline the proceedings.
The prosecution cited a procedure in the case of Congolese rebel leader Bosco Ntaganda wherein the chamber ruled that an expert witness is someone with some specialized knowledge or skill that may assist the chamber in understanding a technical issue that is in question.
Just a little less than a month before Duterte’s trial starts on Nov. 30, the prosecution has been asking the chamber to allow it to introduce into evidence documentary evidence, such as prior recorded testimonies, and associated materials of some of their witnesses.
Detained in an ICC facility, in The Hague, Duterte is accused of being criminally responsible for the drug war killings under a national policy he ordered to combat criminality and illegal drugs. (Kathleen de Villa © Philippine Daily Inquirer)






