Counterpoint: Are Dark Traits Always Bad?
Some argue that certain dark traits can be beneficial in leadership. Narcissists, for instance, may excel in high-risk, high-reward roles — a pattern explored in a 2007 study by scholars Chatterjee and Hambrick. However, the long-term damage to team morale and company culture often outweighs those short-term gains.
Why Traditional Interviews Fail to Catch These Candidates
Most hiring processes are predictable — and that’s exactly what dysfunctional applicants exploit. Standard interviews follow a script, allowing toxic candidates to prepare perfect answers while hiding their true nature. To counter this, HR teams need to rethink their approach.
1. Replace Hypotheticals with Real-Life Scenarios
Instead of asking, “How would you handle a difficult coworker?” (which invites a textbook answer), demand concrete examples: “Give me a specific instance where you clashed with a colleague. What happened, and how did you resolve it?” If their response is vague, contradictory, or full of excuses, probe deeper.
2. Incorporate Psychometric Testing — But Do It Right
Tools like the Hogan Development Survey (HDS) can help identify problematic traits, but they’re only effective when interpreted by professionals. Many companies make the mistake of using these assessments without expert analysis, leading to false positives or missed red flags. This is especially true in many Philippine SMEs, where psychometric tools are often adopted without proper training or interpretation frameworks. In some cases, hiring managers rely solely on raw scores or generic reports—treating personality tests as checklists rather than nuanced diagnostic tools. Hiring a registered psychometrician ensures accurate interpretation—they don’t just read scores; they connect psychological patterns to real workplace behaviors, helping employers make more informed, ethical, and context-sensitive hiring decisions.An important reminder is that the results of this test should never be used in isolation to deny a person with employment.
3. Verify Claims in Real Time
When I was working as a talent acquisition specialist in my first job in Dubai, I started using a simple but surprisingly effective trick during final interviews: I’d politely ask the candidate to send a quick email to a former manager for a reference—right there, on the spot. You’d be amazed how revealing that moment was. The candidates who eagerly agreed usually had nothing to hide. But the ones who stalled, made excuses, or looked uncomfortable? More often than not, their past behavior raised red flags.
- Check References Thoroughly
Many toxic employees have a trail of burned bridges. Ask past employers about teamwork and conflict resolution.
- Look for Patterns in Job-Hopping
Frequent job changes without clear progression may signal interpersonal issues.
The High Cost of a Bad Hire
Toxic hires don’t just underperform—they damage morale, drive good employees away, and cost companies dearly. One study by Simonet and colleagues in 2018 estimates that a single “derailed” executive—someone who flames out due to toxic behavior or poor leadership—can cost a company millions. And unfortunately, such cases aren’t rare.
Final Advice for HR Professionals
Look beyond charm. A candidate who talks a big game but can’t back it up with specifics is likely masking deeper issues.
Listen for blame-shifting. Dysfunctional employees rarely take accountability—they’ll always find someone else at fault.
Trust—but verify. Don’t take polished interview performances at face value. Dig into past behaviors.
Hiring is one of the most critical decisions a company makes. By refining your screening process to catch these red flags early, you’ll save your organization from costly mistakes—and build teams that thrive.
In hiring, precision is compassion—toward both your team and your future hires.
***
Nicasio A. Pimentel III is a UK-certified human resources practitioner and educator with over 15 years of experience spanning HR strategy, analytics, systems integration and talent management across several Fortune Global 500 companies and public sector institutions in UK, Australia and the Middle East. He holds an MSc in Management and Human Resources from the prestigious London School of Economics and a BA Psychology from the University of the Philippines Diliman. A former Christian missionary to marginalized ethnic minorities in Cambodia, he now teaches psychology at the University of Antique and continues to serve underserved communities in Western Visayas through grassroots ministry and education advocacy. He is also an Associate Member of the Chartered Institute of Personnel and Development (Assoc CIPD) in the UK. For questions, e-mail nicasio.pimentel@antiquespride.edu.ph./PN
