25.7 C
Iloilo City
Saturday, November 21, 2026
Home News Nation Sara spox invokes free speech vs Senate impeachment court

Sara spox invokes free speech vs Senate impeachment court

PANELO, DUTERTE-CARPIO
PANELO, DUTERTE-CARPIO

MANILA — Vice President Sara Duterte-Carpio’s spokesperson, lawyer Salvador Paolo Panelo Jr., invoked his constitutional right to free speech as he faced possible contempt proceedings over remarks accusing some senator-judges in the Vice President’s impeachment trial of acting like prosecutors.

Panelo said he was prepared to defend his statements after the Senate impeachment court ordered him to explain why he should not be cited for contempt.

“I welcome the opportunity to demonstrate that my comments were fair, made in good faith, and did not impede, obstruct, or degrade the administration of justice, and are thus constitutionally protected. I will formally respond to the Show Cause Order within the period provided upon receipt,” Panelo said in a statement sent to Panay News.

He maintained that public officials, including members of judicial bodies, are subject to public scrutiny and criticism, arguing that contempt powers should not be used to suppress legitimate commentary.

The controversy arose during the 45th day of Duterte-Carpio’s impeachment trial when senator-judge Erwin Tulfo questioned Panelo’s public statements suggesting that some members of the impeachment court were behaving like prosecutors.

Tulfo raised concerns over Panelo’s comments, particularly because he serves as the Vice President’s spokesperson despite not being formally involved in the proceedings.

Presiding officer Senate President Francis Escudero clarified that Panelo, being neither a lawyer nor a witness in the trial, was not covered by the sub judice restrictions imposed on participants.

However, Escudero said the impeachment court could still invoke its contempt powers under Rule 71 of the Rules of Court, which applies suppletorily to the proceedings.

Tulfo subsequently moved to require Panelo to explain his remarks. With no objection from the senator-judges, Escudero directed the Clerk of Court to issue a show cause order.

In defending his position, Panelo cited the Supreme Court’s 2012 ruling in Garcia Jr. v. Manrique, which recognized the public’s right to criticize government officials, including judicial authorities.

He also invoked the 2026 ruling in Tolentino vs Heydarian, which he said underscored the protection of public discourse on matters of significant public interest and cautioned against using contempt powers to silence legitimate criticism./PN

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here