ILOILO City – The Supreme Court has overturned the dismissal of former Western Visayas police director Bernardo Diaz, voiding administrative proceedings triggered by former president Rodrigo Duterte’s 2016 accusations linking him to illegal drugs and ruling that authorities violated his constitutional right to due process.
In a 22-page resolution dated August 12, 2026, the Court’s First Division granted Diaz’s motion for reconsideration and nullified the proceedings conducted by the National Police Commission (NAPOLCOM), along with subsequent decisions of the Office of the President (OP).
The ruling effectively overturned the penalties imposed on the retired police general, including dismissal from service, cancellation of eligibility, forfeiture of retirement benefits and perpetual disqualification from public office.
“The NAPOLCOM proceedings and the OP Decision and Resolution are void for having been conducted and issued, respectively, in violation of petitioner’s right to due process,” the Court ruled.
The case stemmed from Duterte’s July 7, 2016 public accusation identifying Diaz as one of five Philippine National Police generals allegedly protecting illegal drug operations.
Diaz denied the allegation, but NAPOLCOM subsequently investigated and charged him with grave neglect of duty for allegedly failing to effectively combat illegal drugs in Western Visayas.
However, the Supreme Court found that the investigation violated NAPOLCOM Memorandum Circular No. 2016-002, which governs administrative complaints against police personnel.
The Court noted that the investigation preceded the proper filing of a formal complaint and that Duterte’s public pronouncement could not substitute for a valid administrative complaint under the rules.
“There is a lack of genuine compliance to the procedure under NMC 2016-002,” the resolution stated.
The high tribunal also found that Diaz was not properly informed of the specific allegations against him or given a meaningful opportunity to defend himself.
It emphasized that administrative proceedings must uphold fundamental fairness, including the respondent’s right to know the charges, examine the evidence, present a defense and receive a decision based on substantial evidence.
Diaz had submitted reports and documents detailing anti-drug operations conducted by PRO-6 during his leadership, but the OP questioned their sufficiency and documentation.
The Court found that these issues were not properly addressed during the proceedings.
It also rejected the argument that Diaz’s subsequent motion for reconsideration had corrected the due-process violations.
“Although the OP Decision was modified precisely to conform with the Formal Charge, this will not negate the fact that in the proceedings before the NAPOLCOM, petitioner was not properly notified of the allegations against him,” the resolution stated.
The Supreme Court consequently reversed its July 29, 2024 resolution dismissing Diaz’s petition for certiorari and declared void the OP’s May 10, 2022 decision and March 5, 2024 resolution.
Associate Justice Ramon Paul L. Hernando penned the ruling, concurred in by Chief Justice Alexander G. Gesmundo and Associate Justices Rodil V. Zalameda, Ricardo R. Rosario and Jose Midas P. Marquez.
Diaz headed PRO-6 from June 2015 until July 1, 2016, before being placed under floating status at Camp Crame following Duterte’s accusations.
He consistently denied involvement in illegal drugs, citing his command’s anti-drug accomplishments, and eventually reached mandatory retirement age while contesting the administrative charges.
The ruling reinforces the constitutional requirement that government authorities observe due process even when pursuing serious administrative allegations against public officials./PN





