MANILA — The Supreme Court has challenged Ombudsman Jesus Crispin Remulla to formally report alleged corruption in the judiciary and present supporting evidence, stressing that sweeping public accusations alone cannot trigger an investigation against judges or courts.
Supreme Court spokesperson Camille Ting said the judiciary takes allegations of misconduct, partiality and corruption seriously but cannot act on generalized claims against an entire appellate court without a formal complaint identifying specific wrongdoing.
“We therefore invite the Ombudsman, or any concerned party, to file the proper complaint and submit supporting evidence,” Ting said.
The high court said the filing of a formal complaint would allow it to establish the facts, examine the evidence and determine whether disciplinary action against members of the judiciary is warranted.
The statement came after Remulla raised concerns about alleged corruption in the judiciary amid controversies surrounding court proceedings connected to alleged irregularities in flood control projects.
Remulla has continued to defend the Office of the Ombudsman’s investigations despite the Sandiganbayan’s decision to grant former senator Ramon “Bong” Revilla Jr. bail in a case involving an alleged ghost flood control project.
While calling for allegations to be pursued through established procedures, the Supreme Court stressed that it does not seek to shield the judiciary from legitimate public criticism.
It cited its recent unanimous ruling in the Heydarian, Cendana and Gadon cases recognizing the public’s constitutional protection for freedom of expression, including the right to criticize courts and their decisions.
“At the same time, serious accusations against judges and courts should be raised through the proper processes so they can be fairly investigated and resolved,” Ting said.
The Supreme Court maintained that requiring formal complaints and supporting evidence would ensure that accusations against judges and courts are evaluated on their merits rather than on public statements or broad, unsubstantiated claims./PN
