I JUST watched The Odyssey in the cinema, and while the hyped IMAX delivered, I came out thinking that Troy was still the better movie. So, I thought of comparing the two interrelated (in a way) movies.
Here’s why:
Troy (2004) delivers masterful, easy-to-understand action. The legendary duel between Achilles and Hector relies on physical stunts, perfect rhythm, and wide shots. I remember rooting for Prince Hector in that fight, although I had a premonition that he would die at the end. In that scene, you feel every blow, making it a great cinematic fight.
Meanwhile, in The Odyssey, the focus was on pure tension. It captures the terror of survival from the monsters and the gods, which are treated like psychological hallucinations, turning a straightforward adventure story into a confusing puzzle. Perhaps it was the intent, huh! It was plain killing after killing using all sorts of weapons. The killings were wanton, cruel, and savage. Not that Troy did not use the same savagery, though.
Cinematic aesthetics and characters
Troy provides you exactly what you want from an ancient epic. It features massive sun-drenched beaches, thousands of practical extras, shimmering bronze armor, and towering, majestic city walls. Oh yes, Troy was depicted elaborately. Meanwhile, The Odyssey opts for a bleak, stripped-down aesthetic. The world feels stark and dark, notwithstanding the captivating scenery. While artistic, the approach can make the ancient world feel hollow instead of grand. Of course, it’s the screenwriter and director’s choice.
Troy features larger-than-life heroes. Brad Pitt’s Achilles is the ultimate apex warrior, and Eric Bana’s Hector is the noble, defiant defender. They are captivating, charismatic, and easy to root for. I never saw a handsome Achilles in all my life, haha! But Hector was altogether lovable. Oh yes, he was.
In The Odyssey, Odysseus is portrayed not as a clever hero, but as a traumatized commander making costly mistakes that get his men killed. It was angering to see his men suffer death under his leadership. What a waste!
Hector in Troy represents grounded, family-centered nobility, and practical leadership, often highlighting the human cost of war compared to Greek ambition. At the same time, the 2026 version of The Odyssey emphasizes intense trauma, existential guilt, and the personal cost of his journey. It was tiresome.
Helen: The price of beauty
We cannot talk about Hector’s sacrifice without looking at the woman who inadvertently caused it. Diane Kruger’s Helen of Troy remains a fascinating contrast to how modern cinema tries to manage female mythological figures.
In the original myths, Helen is treated like a prize or a curse. In Troy, she is a prisoner of her own beauty, trapped in a loveless marriage to Menelaus and used as a political pawn by kings who want an excuse to burn a city.
Like Matt Damon’s broken Odysseus, Helen carries immense psychological trauma. But unlike Odysseus, who brings chaos upon himself through his own arrogance, Helen’s tragedy is completely thrust upon her.
Troy (2004) treats Helen as a deeply human, flawed girl trapped in a massive political nightmare. Her romance with Prince Paris isn’t just a fairy tale; it is the spark that accidentally destroys an empire. You feel the heavy, tragic weight of her presence in every scene. Helen of Sparta became Helen of Troy.
In The Odyssey (2026), Nolan barely features Helen, reducing her to a brief, haunting flashback sequence in Odysseus’s mind. She is treated more like an abstract symbol of the war’s origin rather than a real person.
Words that echo through the ages
One of the most powerful, quiet moments in Troy occurs just before the decisive battle, when Helen tells Hector she will give herself up to the Greeks to stop the bloodshed. Hector stops her with absolute compassion:
“It’s too late for that. If you go to Menelaus now, there won’t be peace. Agamemnon will still burn Troy to the ground. You’re a Trojan now. And we protect our own.”
Hector’s quote that really stuck with me, spoken in all his splendor as a warrior, was:
“All my life I’ve lived by a code, and the code is simple: Honor the gods, love your woman, and defend your country. Troy is mother to us all. Fight for her!”
How epic is that! I found it genuinely patriotic and deeply romantic.
Odysseus, a man drowning in survival guilt, wartime trauma, and existential isolation, said:
“The war didn’t end when the city burned. It followed us into the water. It’s inside the wood of the ships. It’s inside me.”
Truly tragic.
In the Troy movie, Achilles perished like Hector, while Odysseus redeemed himself in a killing spree much like the scene in Game of Thrones’ “The Red Wedding,” when all the doors were locked, and Talisa Stark, Robb Stark, Catelyn Stark, and their entire entourage were slaughtered. The carnage was surreal.
There. I hope you shared in my enthusiasm for the movie.
* * *
The author owns and manages Belinda Communications Consulting. You can reach us via email at belca.87@gmail.com. Engage with us on X @ShilohRuthie./PN
